Skip to content
GIO
IN THE DR
← All guides

Travel guides11 min read

Italy vs Dominican Republic: The Best of Both Worlds

I'm Italian, but I've made the Dominican Republic my home. From food and coffee to beaches and lifestyle, here's what I love most about both countries.

Italian expat differences of life in Italy and the Dominican Republic after moving to Cabarete

Italy vs. Dominican Republic: why I choose the best of both worlds

A few weeks ago, I posted a little Instagram carousel sharing some of my personal favorites from Italy and the Dominican Republic.

The title was “Italia vs. República Dominicana (Italy vs. Dominican Republic.

The idea was simple: I picked different things from both countries and circled the ones I personally prefer.

Coffee? Dominican Republic.
Pasta and food? Italy. Obviously.
Beaches? Dominican Republic.
Gelato? Italy. Not even a question.
And boyfriend? Well, the Dominican Republic won that one too!

I thought it would be a fun post, something my Italian and Dominican friends could laugh about. What I didn't expect was for it to go viral.

Suddenly, people were sharing their own favorites, debating my choices, laughing at the fact that I equally prefer Italian AND Dominican beaches, and telling me what they would have picked.

And I loved seeing everyone's reactions!

But here's the thing: these were never meant to be judgments about which country does things better. They were simply my personal preferences, shaped by where I grew up and where I've chosen to live.

Because after spending so many years between Italy and the Dominican Republic, I've realized something. I don't need one country to be better than the other.

I'm lucky enough to enjoy the best of both worlds.

A little about my story

I was born and raised in Italy, and no matter where I live, being Italian will always be part of who I am.

It's in the way I eat, the traditions I grew up with, the importance I give to family, and probably the number of times I talk about food in a single day.

But the Dominican Republic has also been part of my life for a long time.

I've been coming here for approximately 12 years and have now lived in Cabarete for around five. What started as a place I loved visiting eventually became the place where I built my everyday life.

I work here, I have friends here, I play sports here, and I've created routines that make this little corner of the Caribbean feel like home.

The things Italy will always win for me

Pasta, food and the Italian way of eating

Let's get the obvious one out of the way. Italian food will always have a special place in my heart. And I don't mean only pizza and pasta.

I mean the entire food culture: sitting down for a proper meal, family recipes, seasonal ingredients, fresh bread, homemade pasta, and those lunches that somehow turn into an entire afternoon. I miss Italian supermarkets!

Being vegetarian since birth, I also love how many traditional Italian dishes naturally fit the way I eat. A simple plate of pasta with good tomatoes, fresh basil, and olive oil can make me happier than a complicated meal.

It's the kind of food I grew up eating, and I never get tired of it. Of course, that doesn't mean I don't enjoy Dominican food.
I love it! As much as I love discovering local dishes, fresh ingredients, and all the different flavors you find around the island.

But when it comes to my personal favorite cuisine, Italy wins. I think my Italian family would be concerned if I said otherwise.

Gelato: a very important Italian tradition

I don't think this one needs much explanation. Italian gelato is one of those things I always look forward to when I go home, the artisanal one.

Walking around town, stopping at a gelateria, and choosing between flavors I've loved since childhood is such a simple pleasure.

And yes, I know there are good ice cream shops in the Dominican Republic. But there's something about having a proper Italian gelato while walking through a beautiful piazza (the town square) that just feels right.

It's not only about the taste. It's also about the memories attached to it.

Wine and those long Italian evenings

Italy also wins my wine category. Not because I think you can't enjoy a good glass of wine elsewhere, but because wine is so connected to the Italian lifestyle I grew up around.

A glass with dinner, an aperitivo with friends, or a long evening around the table. I love how food, conversation, and wine naturally come together.

When I'm back in Italy, these are some of the little rituals I appreciate most.
And the older I get, the more I realize that sometimes it's not about doing anything extraordinary. Just enjoying the moment with the right people.

Fashion: my Italian side is showing

I had to give fashion to Italy too. I love Italian style, from the attention to fabrics and details to the way people put together outfits for everyday life.

There's something about walking through an Italian city and seeing how people dress that always inspires me.

Living in Cabarete, my wardrobe has inevitably changed. I spend a lot more time in sandals, shorts, summer dresses, and beach clothes.

I love this type of freedom. But whenever I go back to Italy, I enjoy dressing up a little more. It's almost like switching between two versions of myself.

The things that made me fall in love with the Dominican Republic

Dominican coffee: I really chose it over Italian coffee

This was probably one of my more controversial choices! I'm Italian. I grew up with espresso culture and Nespresso machines. I know how seriously Italians take their coffee.

But, I chose Dominican coffee. I love its flavor, its aroma, and the ritual of having a little cafecito (filtered coffee for me is the best one).

There's something about drinking Dominican coffee in the morning, especially when I’m at home, in my tropical yard or sitting outside in the sunshine, that I enjoy.

Does this mean I've stopped loving Italian espresso? NO!
I still love going to an Italian bar, ordering a coffee, and drinking it standing at the counter. But it doesn’t taste the same.

Sorry, Italy!

Beaches: love both, but the Caribbean has good weather all year round

This was actually a tie in my Instagram carousel!

Italy has some absolutely beautiful beaches, and I love spending summer days by the Mediterranean Sea and Sardinia. From the colorful coastal towns to the crystal-clear water, there's so much to love. And the amazing day-trips on the yacht exploring the surrounding smaller islands.

But there's one thing the Dominican Republic has that Italy doesn't: warm ocean water all year round!

I love being able to go for a swim in January, February, or whenever I feel like it, without having to wait for summer.

Living in Cabarete makes it even better. The beach is part of my everyday life, from a morning walk, watching the kites in the afternoon, or enjoying a sunset by the ocean.

So when it comes to beautiful beaches, I choose both. But for year-round swimming, the Dominican Republic definitely has my heart.

Tropical fruit: my everyday Caribbean luxury

Mangoes, passion fruit (chinola), pineapple (piña), papaya (lechoza), avocado…

I could keep going. I love tropical fruit, and living in the Dominican Republic means having access to so many fresh, delicious options.

There's something wonderful about buying fruit locally and enjoying it when it's perfectly ripe. Not to mention the price… and mango season!!

When I'm in Italy, I appreciate the seasonal fruit I grew up with, especially during summer. But when it comes to tropical fruit, the Dominican Republic wins for me.

Music and parties: the Dominican energy is contagious

If you've spent time in the Dominican Republic, you probably know what I'm talking about. Music is everywhere. Bachata, merengue, salsa…

You'll hear it at restaurants, on the beach, at family gatherings, and sometimes when you least expect it. I love how music is such a natural part of social life.

And when it comes to parties and weddings, I also gave the Dominican Republic my vote. It’s the spontaneity of getting together, dancing, laughing, and turning an ordinary evening into a fun memory.

Of course, Italy has incredible nightlife, festivals, and celebrations too. But personally, I love the energy of Dominican parties, where you don't even need a special occasion. Good music and good company are enough.

And then there was the boyfriend slide…

I couldn't make a post talking about Italy and the Dominican Republic without including something a little more personal. So, I added one last slide.

Boyfriend.

And of course, the Dominican Republic won ;). I do have a Dominican boyfriend. It would have been a little awkward to choose Italy! Hahah!

Relationships are also a big part of why a place becomes home. It's not just the weather, the food, or the beaches. It's the people you share your life with. And that's something the Dominican Republic has given me too.

Why I choose the Dominican Republic for my lifestyle

Now we get to the most important category in my carousel.
Lifestyle: Dominican Republic.

And if you ask me where I would choose to live today, my answer is still the Dominican Republic. Not because Italy isn't beautiful. Not because life here is (almost) perfect.

Every country has its advantages, challenges, and things that can drive you a little crazy.

But the lifestyle I've created in Cabarete makes me happy happy. I love being able to spend so much time outdoors. I love the warm weather, the ocean, the possibility of playing padel or tennis, practicing yoga, meeting friends for coffee, or going for a beach walk without having to plan an entire weekend around it.

I love how connected everyday life feels to nature. And I love that even when I have a busy workday, I can often finish it with a little time outside.
That doesn't mean I'm on vacation all the time. I have responsibilities, deadlines, stressful days, and all the normal things that come with working and living somewhere.

But the environment around me makes a difference.

Quality of life isn't only about what I do for work or how much I earn. It's also about how I feel during a normal day. And that's where Cabarete really wins my heart.

Going back to Italy makes me appreciate both countries even more

One of the nicest things about living abroad is that returning home makes you notice details you might have stopped appreciating before.

When I go back to Italy, I look forward to seeing my family, enjoying familiar places, eating my favorite foods, and spending time in the environment where I grew up.

I love walking through Italian towns, enjoying the architecture, the urban organization and recycling.

Sometimes, being away makes those experiences even more special. But after a while, I start missing Cabarete. I miss the ocean, the tropical weather, my everyday routines, and the life I've built there. I start craving Dominican coffee again.

That's when I realize that home isn't necessarily just one place anymore. Italy is where my story began. The Dominican Republic is where I'm writing another important chapter of it.

The best of both worlds isn't about choosing a winner

Looking back at my Instagram carousel, I still stand by my choices.
Italian pasta, gelato, fashion, and wine + Dominican coffee, beaches, tropical fruit, music, parties, and lifestyle.

But those choices don't mean that one country is better than the other.
They're simply the things I enjoy most.

Living between two cultures is challenging at first but fun and something to be thankful for.

You discover new habits, develop different tastes, and start appreciating things you might never have experienced if you'd stayed in the same place your entire life. You don't have to stop loving where you come from to fall in love with somewhere new.

I'll always be Italian. But the Dominican Republic is the home I've chosen.

Having roots in one place and building a life somewhere else is beautiful <3

I'm grateful for everything Italy has given me, and I'm equally grateful for the experiences, relationships, and lifestyle I've found in the Dominican Republic.

So no, Italy and the Dominican Republic don’t need to compete.
I'm just happy I get to enjoy the best of both worlds.

What about you?

Have you ever lived abroad or spent enough time in another country that it started to feel like home?

What are the things you love most about your home country? And what have you discovered somewhere else that you wish you could bring back with you?

And if you have an Italian or Dominican friend who would enjoy this little comparison, send them this article (thanks fro sharing!).

See you in Cabarete!

Gio

Gio in the DR ~ Properties, Lifestyle & Relocation

Keep reading

Hi, I'm Gio 👋
What brings you to the DR?
🏠 Buying a home📈 Investing on the north coast🛂 Relocating & residencyChat on WhatsApp

Replies in English · Español · Italiano. An AI assistant will answer common questions here soon.